CA School Board Defies Bonta, Keeps Boys Out of Girls Sports

0
30

By Bash Harvey CBNC News

Picture a school board meeting in California’s Inland Empire where a mom holds up a letter from Attorney General Rob Bonta’s office telling her to back off, and then tears it in half. That was Sonja Shaw on Thursday night at her final meeting as president of the Chino Valley Unified School District board, and the board then voted 4-1 to keep biological males out of girls sports, locker rooms, and restrooms.

The policy is called “Fairness in Girls’ Athletics and Privacy in Sex-Based Facilities,” and it does what the title says. Eligibility for girls teams is set by biological sex at birth, checked against enrollment records. If those records are missing or have been amended, a student can provide an original birth certificate or a signed statement from a health care provider based on a routine sports physical. The policy bars any examination beyond that physical.

Restrooms, locker rooms, and overnight trip accommodations must be separated by biological sex. No girl can be disciplined for refusing to compete against or share a facility with a biological male. Any student who wants a single-user restroom or private space gets one, no questions asked. The rules cover a district of about 26,000 students in San Bernardino County.

Sacramento saw it coming. On Wednesday, Deputy Attorney General Edward Nugent wrote to the district that the proposal conflicts with the state Education Code and urged the board to reject it or at least delay the vote. California law has let students join teams and use facilities matching their gender identity since 2013. Shaw said the board also received a cease-and-desist demand from the California Teachers Association.

Shaw’s answer went out on X with Bonta tagged. “Federal law is supreme,” she wrote. “Look it up.” She added: “I will never back down from protecting our daughters. You picked the wrong fight with this mom.”

Opponents, including the group Trans Kids Belong, say the policy is clearly illegal under California law and will cost the district millions in court. Here is the fact they skip. The U.S. Supreme Court has already upheld similar policies in other states, and Shaw says Chino Valley’s rule follows that same logic. She wants the district to be a “decisive California test case” and a blueprint for other districts that are tired of waiting on Sacramento.

The vote was not unanimous. Board member Andrew Cruz voted no after trying to push the decision to the new board. Shaw called that “cowardly.” The meeting ran three hours, public comment ran well over an hour, and Shaw had disruptive speakers removed.

The politics around her shifted this month. Shaw gave up her seat to run for state superintendent of public instruction and lost. Her husband, Chris Shaw, lost his race for her seat, and conservative incumbent Shaun Smith also lost. Conservatives still hold a 3-2 majority, so the policy is likely to stand once the new board is seated.

This is the gap between the capital and the kitchen. In Sacramento, the fight is about statutes and gender identity rules. In Chino, parents are asking a simpler question about who belongs in the girls’ locker room.

If Bonta sues, California taxpayers will pay for the state’s lawyers and the district’s defense at the same time, all to force onto girls’ teams a policy the nation’s highest court has already let other states reject.

Sources:
latimes.com/california/story/2026-11-20/chino-valley-unified-school-board-bans-transgender-students-girls-sports-restrooms
edsource.org/2026/sonja-shaw-girls-sports-policy/770945
intheminutes.org/chino-valley-usd/summary/2026-11-19
californiaexpres.com/local-news/chino-valley-unified-school-board-president-sonja-shaw-proposes-transgender-sports-ban-at-final-meeting

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here