Photo – Official Portrait
By Zorina Grey CBNC News
The Pentagon told America’s European allies in Brussels on Tuesday that Washington will judge the Ukraine war by results on the front line and by the American interest in ending it, not by the spectacle of drones over Russian cities. Elbridge Colby, the Under Secretary for Policy at the Pentagon, delivered that assessment to the Ukraine Defense Contact Group at NATO headquarters, and Germany answered by calling it stupid.
Colby’s message was direct. He said the public conversation has focused on the spectacle of deep strikes meant to inflict pain on the Russian population, and that the American assessment is that those strikes have not been effective in driving an end to the war or in blunting Russia’s advances on the front line. He said strikes on civilian targets, naming the Russian retailer Wildberries, have probably hardened Russian public resolve and the Kremlin’s willingness to escalate. He added that the balance of advantage in deep strikes may well favor Moscow.
The strategic objective behind that assessment is plain. Washington wants the war brought to a negotiated end, with fresh peace talks expected in the coming weeks and President Trump in China this week for talks with Xi Jinping and Vladimir Putin that include Ukraine. Colby said Western support should go first to helping Ukraine hold the line of battle and, where possible, make gains, including medium-range strikes on Russian logistics behind the front. He said explicitly that Ukraine should not be forced to fight with its hands tied behind its back. The alternative left in place is the current course: a long-range campaign that produces headlines while the front line moves the wrong way.
German Defense Minister Boris Pistorius rejected the assessment after the meeting. He said criticizing Ukrainian strikes on strategic military targets inside Russia was quite a stupid thing, and that allies should instead talk about Russian strikes on Ukraine’s energy, water, and heating systems. British Defense Secretary Wes Streeting said it is not for allies to tell Ukraine how to fight, and that deep strikes have degraded Russia’s war machine.
The collectivist claim is that the alliance must back every Ukrainian tactical choice without question and that any American dissent betrays the common cause. That claim fails on capacity. The United States no longer pays directly for Ukraine’s war. Under the NATO-backed PURL program, European allies buy American weapons for Kyiv, and Colby urged ministers to keep that money flowing so Ukrainian troops can hold the front. NATO allies remain billions short of their own 70 billion euro aid target for this year and of a separate 12 billion euro goal for PURL. Several countries, including Germany, Norway, and Sweden, announced more than 300 million dollars in new contributions on Tuesday. Capitals that have not met their own pledges are poorly placed to lecture the country whose factories supply the munitions.
The claim also fails on incentives. Colby told European governments that the United States understands their populations want to benefit from higher defense spending, but that a secure Europe needs American systems such as the F-35. He said Washington is not insisting on American-only production and wants a pragmatic, balanced relationship. That is an ally asking partners to carry their own defense and to buy the best equipment available while they do it. It is not abandonment.
The disagreement in Brussels is therefore not about whether Ukraine may defend itself. It is about who decides American strategy and who pays for it. Washington has set its objective as ending the war on terms the front line can support. Berlin answered with an insult while the alliance it speaks for remains billions short of its own funding target.
Sources:
https://redstate.com/streiff/2026/11/17/fireworks-at-nato-german-defense-minister-calls-american-position-on-ukraine-quite-a-stupid-thing-n2209537
https://justthenews.com/politics-policy/all-things-trump/trump-arrives-china-where-hell-talk-iran-ukraine-and-nuclear-arms-xi-and-putin
https://www.stripes.com/theaters/europe/2026-11-18/colby-ukraine-nato-strike-dispute-23503481.html
https://www.politico.eu/article/us-scold-ukraine-strikes-russia-peace-talks-elbridge-colby/
https://www.kyivpost.com/post/90414




