FL AG Uthmeier Declares Bump-Stock Ban Unconstitutional and Refuses to Defend Convictions

0
84

Photo – Screenshot from USCCA.com

By Nick “The Bulldog” Benson CBNC News

Florida Attorney General James Uthmeier declared in Tallahassee, Florida, on Friday that the state’s 2018 bump-stock ban violates the Second Amendment, and he announced that his office will no longer defend a single conviction obtained under it.

Uthmeier did it with a six-page formal legal opinion dated November 13 and posted to X that afternoon. The opinion answers one question, whether section 790.222 of the Florida Statutes violates the Second Amendment, and Uthmeier answered it directly. “After careful consideration, I have determined that it does,” he wrote. The opinion closes with the operative line: “Section 790.222 therefore violates the Second Amendment and cannot be lawfully enforced by Executive Branch officials in Florida. This Office will not defend a conviction under section 790.222.”

The law was passed in March 2018 as part of the Marjory Stoneman Douglas High School Public Safety Act, Senate Bill 7026, which also raised the minimum age to buy a rifle in Florida to 21 and created the state’s red flag law. It cleared the House 67 to 50, and then-Governor Rick Scott signed it on March 9, 2018, telling the public that every side had to give a little. Uthmeier answered that line eight years later. “The Constitution, however, brooks little compromise when it comes to citizens’ fundamental rights,” he wrote. Tallahassee spent eight years treating a constitutional right as a bargaining chip, and the chief legal officer of the state just took the chip off the table.

The cost of that bargain has landed on ordinary gun owners. The statute makes it a third-degree felony to possess, sell, transfer, or give away a bump-fire stock, with a penalty of up to five years in prison. In his post announcing the opinion, Uthmeier said Floridians are being arrested and prosecuted under the law and that, as written, it reaches trigger enhancements that gun owners use for lawful purposes. The opinion cites an ATF estimate that more than 500,000 bump-fire stocks are in private hands nationwide.

The legal reasoning follows the Supreme Court’s own road map. In Garland v. Cargill in 2024, the Court ruled 6 to 3 that a rifle fitted with a bump stock is not a machine gun under federal law, because each shot still requires a separate function of the trigger. Applying the history test from Bruen and this year’s Wolford v. Lopez, Uthmeier concluded that semiautomatic rifles with such modifications are bearable arms covered by the plain text of the Second Amendment and that Florida could point to no historical tradition of banning accessories that speed up a trigger’s reset. He noted that bump stocks were originally developed to help disabled shooters. He also drew a limit, writing that the opinion does not mean the state could never regulate devices that truly convert a firearm into a machine gun.

The ban is still on the books. Only the Legislature or a court can remove it, and the opinion does not bind the state attorneys who file charges in Florida’s 20 judicial circuits. What it does is remove the attorney general’s office, which handles the state’s criminal appeals, from the business of defending those convictions. It follows a November 6 memorandum from the same office telling police that possessing an unregistered short-barreled rifle is not a state crime, although federal rules still apply.

The political ground is shifting with it. Governor-elect Byron Donalds, who takes office in January, voted against the 2018 package as a state lawmaker and criticized its gun provisions during his campaign.

Florida gun owners have lived for eight years under a felony that the state’s own top lawyer now says should never have been written, and every one of them prosecuted in the meantime paid that cost alone.

Sources
https://ammosight.com/news/florida-2026-bump-stock-ban-attorney-general-opinion
https://www.cbsnews.com/miami/news/florida-attorney-general-james-uthmeier-bump-stock-ban-unconstitutional/
https://www.wusf.org/courts-law/2026-11-14/uthmeier-declares-bump-stock-ban-dead
https://www.myfloridalegal.com/sites/default/files/From%20the%20desk%20documents/signed_bump-stock-ago.pdf

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here