Alaska Judge Slams the Door on DEM Mary Peltola’s Demand for a Rejected-Ballot Voter List in the Middle of the Senate Count

0
183

By Jennifer Sanchez CBNC News

Anchorage Superior Court Judge Thomas Matthews ruled on Wednesday, November 11, 2026, that Alaska’s Division of Elections does not have to build and hand over a list identifying voters whose absentee ballots were rejected, along with the reasons for each rejection, to the campaign of Democrat U.S. Senate candidate Mary Peltola while the state is still counting ballots in her race against Republican Sen. Dan Sullivan. Matthews found that the Alaska Public Records Act does not require the division to prepare a custom report for a campaign and that the request was “simply not reasonable nor required right now.”

The Peltola campaign filed the suit on Friday, November 6, against the state. It asked for the records by November 25, the date on which the election is scheduled to be certified, and said it wanted to ensure that its voters’ ballots were properly counted. The Sullivan campaign intervened. In its filing, the Sullivan campaign argued that Peltola wanted the data in order to “seek to influence election officials’ decisions whether to count those ballots” outside the state’s established process for reviewing absentee ballots, which would have put Sullivan at an unfair disadvantage.

The court’s reasoning turned on the statute and on the calendar. Matthews wrote that the public records law allows an agency to provide electronic services and products from public records, but that such services “may not take priority over the primary responsibilities of a public agency.” He called that point “critical.” The division, he wrote, “is actively in the middle of counting ballots,” has deadlines it must meet, and has staff “working long hours to accomplish its fundamental responsibility — administering elections.” He concluded that “the timing of the Campaign’s request could simply not be worse.” He also noted that the campaign first requested the records on October 27, after the division had already set its review procedures and voters were already casting absentee ballots.

The ruling also addressed the mechanics. The information exists in the state’s aging voter registration database, known as VREMS. Matthews found that producing the names and rejection reasons while redacting voters’ addresses would require the state to buy a new software program from its vendor. Assistant Attorney General Margaret Paton-Walsh argued at the Tuesday hearing that voters who cast defective absentee ballots have a privacy interest in not being publicly identified. Alaska has no ballot-curing process that allows voters to fix errors such as a missing signature or improper witnessing after the fact.

The campaign’s own lawyer narrowed its case at the hearing. Attorney Abha Kelly told the court that the process was “going incredibly smoothly,” and the campaign conceded that it had no reason to believe there were irregularities in how absentee ballots were being accepted or rejected. Matthews said from the bench that the case was “not about who won or lost the election.”

The stakes are control of the last undecided Senate seat of the cycle. With roughly 86 percent of the expected vote counted, Peltola held 121,487 first-choice votes, or 48.9 percent, to Sullivan’s 117,512, or 47.3 percent, a margin of 3,975 that narrowed after Wednesday night’s ballot release. Because neither candidate has a majority, the race will go to ranked-choice tabulation after the absentee deadline on November 18. Two other candidates hold more than 9,500 first-choice votes combined, more than the gap between the leaders. A ballot measure to repeal ranked-choice voting was trailing 52.5 percent to 47.5 percent.

The Alaska Department of Law welcomed the decision. Spokesman Sam Curtis said the division “remains committed to its mission of ensuring Alaska’s elections are administered fairly, accurately, and in accordance with the law.” The practical effect is that the absentee review will proceed under the rules that were in place before the first ballot was cast, without a list of rejected voters in the hands of one campaign.

Sources
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/peltola-campaign-loses-court-rejected-absentee-ballots-maintains-narrow-lead
https://www.adn.com/politics/2026/11/11/judge-denies-request-by-peltola-campaign-for-absentee-ballot-data-from-alaska-division-of-elections/
https://apnews.com/article/alaska-senate-peltola-absentee-ballots-sullivan-f42a49a45a2870786f36086c7ad02824
https://thehill.com/regulation/court-battles/6215086-judge-denies-peltola-ballot-request/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here