Main Street Can’t Fill 36% of Its Jobs as Tax Worries Spike to Highest Level Since 2021

0
193
Red now hiring sign hanging in a storefront window, announcing job vacancies and the availability of work positions, indicating a business is actively recruiting new employees

By Billy Ray Valentine CBNC Business News

Thirty-six percent. That’s the share of small business owners who had a job open in October and nobody to fill it. Not a big-box chain. Not a Fortune 500 boardroom. The guy with the welding shop, the woman with the landscaping crew, the family that runs the diner. They’re hiring. They’re raising pay. And the line out the door is empty. So who pays? The owner who meets payroll every Friday, that’s who.

And here’s the part that should make your coffee go cold. Taxes just jumped 10 points to become the No. 2 headache on Main Street, the highest level since May 2021. This is America. The people who still pay their bills, who sign the front of the paycheck, are getting squeezed from both sides. Can’t find the worker. Can’t escape the tax man. Any system that makes it easier to sit out than to show up is promoting bad behavior, and the small business owner is the one carrying the water for it.

The numbers come from the National Federation of Independent Business, which released its October Small Business Optimism Index on Tuesday, Nov. 10, 2026. The index came in at 97.8, down 0.1 point from September, just under the survey’s 53-year average of 98.0 and the lowest reading since June.

Labor is still the No. 1 problem, for the fourth straight month. Twenty-five percent of owners named the quality or availability of workers as their single biggest issue. The historical average is 12%. That’s more than double the normal level of pain.

Dig into the hiring numbers and it gets worse. According to NFIB’s October jobs report, released Nov. 6, 56% of owners were hiring or trying to hire, up 5 points. But 86% of those hiring said they found few or no qualified applicants. One in five owners reported zero qualified applicants. Thirty-one percent had openings for skilled workers, up 4 points.

So owners are doing what you do when you need hands. They’re paying up. A net 29% raised compensation in October. A net 24% plan to raise it in the next three months, the highest since December 2025. Good for the worker who shows up. That’s the market working.

But somebody has to cover that bill, and Main Street is passing it down the line. A net 37% of owners plan to raise prices, up 6 points and the highest since July 2022. A net 13% said they paid a higher interest rate on their most recent loan, the highest since August 2024. Higher wages, higher prices, higher borrowing costs, and a tax line that just leapt 10 points. That’s the squeeze.

The big picture says the demand is there. The Labor Department reported 165,000 jobs added in October, with unemployment falling to 4.1% and factories adding 19,000 jobs, according to Breitbart News. Job openings hit 7.52 million in September. Manufacturing openings climbed to 584,000, the National Association of Manufacturers said. Yet the labor force participation rate sat at 61.9%. The work is out there. Too many Americans aren’t in the line for it.

That’s the moral hazard. When policy rewards staying on the sidelines and taxes the people who build, you get exactly this: open jobs, rising prices, and owners who say taxes are suddenly their second-biggest problem. Debt is not free and neither is a vacant shift. The next generation inherits both.

The people who carry the water are still out there, opening at six, closing at ten, posting the “Now Hiring” sign one more time. They shouldn’t have to beg Washington for a break while they compete for workers who won’t show up. Lower the tax load on the producer. Stop subsidizing the drink-the-water crowd. Let Main Street hire.

Sources:
https://www.nfib.com/news/press-release/new-nfib-survey-main-street-optimism-remains-steady-uncertainty-declines-in-october/
https://www.nfib.com/news/press-release/nfib-jobs-report-october-small-business-jobs-numbers-strengthen-12/
https://www.sharecast.com/news/international-economic/wall-street-nyse-dow-jones-nasdaq-nfib-small-business-optimism–24108558.html
Breitbart News, October jobs report: https://breitbart.news/massive-jobs-blowout-the-u-s-economy-added-165000-jobs-in-october-unemployment-rate-fell-to-4-1-3/
National Association of Manufacturers, September manufacturing job openings (Nov. 9, 2026): https://nam.org/manufacturing-job-openings-climbed-to-584000-in-september-as-rates-rose/
Council of Industry of Southeastern New York, Nov. 9 member briefing (participation rate, wages): https://members.councilofindustry.org/news/member-briefingnovember-9-2026

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here