The Supreme Court heard oral arguments Tuesday for Department of Labor vs. Sun Valley Orchards, with the justices taking turns grilling the latter’s lawyer.
Rob Johnson, arguing on behalf of Sun Valley Orchards, contended that imposing penalties over immigration contracts was a power reserved for courts, not the Executive Branch’s internal adjudication. Johnson faced criticism from both the liberal and conservative justices on the Supreme Court with lawyers representing the Department of Labor (DOL) also rebutting Johnson, arguing that Supreme Court precedent established the Executive Branch’s power to levy such penalties in immigration cases.
“I feel at the base of your argument, Mr. Johnson, you’re trying to get us to think that the H2A program is not an immigration program. But it is an immigration program. It’s all about when do we allow the admission of foreign…




