By Johnny Tango CBNC News
Senate Republicans looked at the worst election night their party has suffered in decades on Tuesday and decided the man in charge of it should keep the job, reelecting South Dakota Sen. John Thune as their leader by acclamation after the conservatives who demanded a reckoning were outvoted 31-15.
The vote to push ahead came after three closed-door meetings on Tuesday, and the 31-15 margin comes from people familiar with the private tally. Wisconsin Sen. Ron Johnson, who led the effort to slow things down, walked out of the room once his colleagues voted to proceed. He had promised he would do exactly that. “If you hold the election, I’ll leave the room,” Johnson told the Washington Examiner on Monday. He kept his word, which already puts him ahead of most of the building.
The rebels were not a fringe. Johnson gathered the five signatures needed to force a full conference meeting, with Sens. Rick Scott of Florida, Mike Lee of Utah, Ted Budd of North Carolina and John Kennedy of Louisiana signing his letter. Sens. Dave McCormick of Pennsylvania and Jim Banks of Indiana backed a delay in their own statements. Missouri Sen. Josh Hawley said he was “not happy” and refused to pledge his vote in advance. Scott, who chairs the Senate Steering Committee, demanded a written roadmap for the lame-duck session and for the next Congress before anyone handed out gavels.
They had reason to ask. Republicans lost at least seven Senate seats on November 3, including those held by Ohio Sen. Jon Husted and Maine Sen. Susan Collins, and Democrats will take control of the chamber in January. “That kind of defeat demands change,” Johnson said Monday. McCormick put it in plain language: “A week ago, we had the worst election result in decades.”
The leadership answer was to change almost nothing. Thune stays on top. Wyoming Sen. John Barrasso stays as whip. Arkansas Sen. Tom Cotton stays as conference chair. Shelley Moore Capito of West Virginia keeps the Policy Committee, and James Lankford of Oklahoma keeps the vice chair slot. The single new face is Ohio Sen. Bernie Moreno, who takes over the National Republican Senatorial Committee from Sen. Tim Scott. Thune’s spokesman said every member of the team was elected without dissent.
The establishment case is that there was no one else and no point in waiting. “If everyone has a chance to have their say, and somebody else isn’t running, it seems to me like it’s time to have the vote and go ahead,” North Dakota Sen. John Hoeven said Monday. The trouble is that nobody ran precisely because the conference never stopped long enough to ask what went wrong. Johnson admitted the problem himself when reporters asked him for an alternative. “That’s part of our problem. Who’d want the job?” he said.
Senate Republicans treated a seven-seat wipeout the way a man treats a blinking check-engine light. They put a strip of tape over it and voted to keep driving the same car.
Meanwhile, the work that voters sent a Republican Senate to do is still sitting on the shelf. The lame-duck session is the last window in which a Republican majority can confirm President Donald Trump’s nominees and move the House-passed agenda before Democrats take the floor in January. The conservatives asked for a plan to use that window. The conference gave them a secret ballot and a door to walk out of.
The cost lands on the voters who stuck with the party through a brutal cycle. They were promised a fighting Senate. They got the same leadership team, the same strategy and the same people explaining that the moment calls for patience. Washington lost seven seats and called it a vote of confidence. America First voters will remember which senators walked out and which ones stayed seated.
Sources: https://apnews.com/article/john-thune-republican-leadership-elections-aee05eef5d85aafde6fbb27272977a14 https://www.axios.com/2026/11/10/senate-republicans-john-thune-leadership-elections https://www.nbcnews.com/politics/congress/republicans-reeling-election-choose-leadership-congress-rcna608300 https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/6210906-senate-gop-leadership-vote-paused/ https://thehill.com/homenews/senate/6209947-scott-hawley-decline-thune-reelection/ https://www.cbsnews.com/live-updates/congress-today-senate-house-leadership-elections/ https://punchbowl.news/article/washington/despite-grumbling-thune-poised-for-leadership/
Visuals:
- Sen. John Thune speaking to reporters outside the Old Senate Chamber after Tuesday’s leadership vote (wire photo, Nov. 10, 2026).
- Sen. Ron Johnson leaving the Old Senate Chamber or talking with reporters in a Capitol hallway on Tuesday.
- Republican senators filing out of the Old Senate Chamber between Tuesday’s closed-door meetings.
- Optional graphic: “Delay motion failed 31-15” with the full returning leadership slate (Thune, Barrasso, Cotton, Capito, Lankford) and Moreno as new NRSC chair.




