Judge Won’t Let Tren de Aragua Suspects Hide Names

0
94
United States Court House. Courthouse facade with columns, lower Manhattan, New York

By Jennifer Sanchez CBNC News

U.S. District Judge James Wesley Hendrix, appointed by President Donald Trump, denied a request on Friday to let the proposed class representatives in W.M.M. v. Trump, the Alien Enemies Act challenge over alleged Tren de Aragua members, proceed under pseudonyms, ruling that the Venezuelan petitioners had not backed their fears with evidence.

The order, issued in the Northern District of Texas and reported by Eugene Volokh at Reason on Monday, turns on a short holding. The three class representatives, identified in court papers as D.A.A., T.I.A. and E.A.A., did not show that disclosing their names would force them to reveal information of the utmost intimacy, and they did not show a plausible threat of harm if their identities become public. Hendrix wrote that the petitioners “have not substantiated their conclusory allegations with evidence that they will suffer harm if their identities are disclosed.”

The background is the President’s March 14, 2025 proclamation invoking the Alien Enemies Act, a federal statute that lets the president remove foreign nationals engaged in an “invasion or predatory incursion” against the United States. The proclamation targets members of Tren de Aragua, which the order describes as a Venezuelan terrorist group that traffics drugs and engages in other criminal activity. The petitioners filed a habeas action on behalf of a proposed class of Venezuelan nationals detained under the proclamation. After trips to the Fifth Circuit and the Supreme Court, the matter is back before Hendrix.

The judge leaned on Fifth Circuit precedent. Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 10(a) requires plaintiffs to name themselves in the complaint, and the Fifth Circuit recognizes a “strong presumption against party pseudonymity.” Hendrix quoted that court for the proposition that “judicial records belong to the American people; they are public, not private, documents.” Pseudonyms are allowed in cases involving matters of a sensitive and highly personal nature, or where a party faces threatened harm, and he found neither here.

On the first point, the petitioners did not claim that disclosure would reveal their religion, sexuality or family life. They wanted anonymity because they did not want to publicize an alleged connection to Tren de Aragua. The court said the Fifth Circuit has never treated that kind of information as sensitive and highly personal. The petitioners also dispute that they are gang members, and Hendrix observed that the Fifth Circuit has implied pseudonymity is proper only when the sensitive information is true.

On asylum, two petitioners, T.I.A. and E.A.A., have asylum applications. The petitioners cited a federal regulation that bars disclosure of information contained in an asylum application. Hendrix answered that disclosing their names reveals only that they applied, not what the applications say, and that the court lacks jurisdiction over asylum applications in any event.

On threatened harm, the petitioners submitted new evidence not previously before the Fifth Circuit: an expert declaration describing threats to alleged gang members from Venezuelan paramilitary groups, opposition figures and rival gangs, and describing how the Venezuelan government uses detainees held at the CECOT prison in Tecoluca, El Salvador, in political propaganda. Hendrix found that the declaration still offered only “generalized concerns.” It listed no express threats of violence and no specific past incidents, and it did not connect disclosure in this lawsuit to any future harm. He noted that the Venezuelan regime singled out the CECOT detainees because of where they were held, not because of a lawsuit in the United States.

The order also corrects the court’s own earlier practice. Hendrix had granted the original named petitioners pseudonyms in a summary order at the start of the case because of their immigration histories. He wrote that he did so on a rapid timeline, and that the en banc Fifth Circuit’s later statement and the lack of compelling new evidence made denial appropriate now.

The ruling does not decide whether the Alien Enemies Act proclamation exceeds presidential authority, and it does not decide whether the detainees received enough notice to contest removal. Those merits questions remain pending. The Fifth Circuit, sitting en banc, dismissed an earlier version of the case as moot in August because the named plaintiffs had been removed under the Immigration and Nationality Act instead.

The practical effect is that the people asking an American court to stop their removal as terrorists must now put their names on the record that the American public is entitled to read. No justice voted on this order, so there is no scorecard to report.

Sources
https://reason.com/volokh/2026/11/09/plaintiffs-contesting-tren-de-aragua-membership-claims-alien-enemies-act-application-still-cant-sue-pseudonymously/
https://law.justia.com/cases/federal/appellate-courts/ca5/25-10534/25-10534-2026-08-13.html
https://reason.com/volokh/2026/08/13/en-banc-fifth-circuit-dismisses-alien-enemies-act-case-as-moot/
https://www.foxnews.com/politics/trumps-fight-rarely-used-18th-century-deportation-law-lives-latest-court-clash

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here