Obama Judge Chutkan Blocks Trump Arch Hours After Approval

0
274

By Jennifer Sanchez CBNC News

U.S. District Judge Tanya Chutkan, appointed by President Barack Obama, issued a 14-day temporary restraining order late Thursday, November 5, 2026, barring the Trump administration from any construction work on the planned 250-foot arch at Memorial Circle, the traffic island on Arlington Memorial Bridge between the Lincoln Memorial and Arlington National Cemetery. The order landed less than two hours after the National Capital Planning Commission gave the project final approval.

The commission voted 8 to 4 after a hearing that ran nearly eight hours. The administration had told the court that it intended to begin work immediately after approval. Chutkan’s order was finalized and made public minutes after she signed it, and it rests on a 33-page opinion.

The holding has two parts. First, Chutkan concluded that the plaintiffs are likely to show the project violates the Commemorative Works Act of 1986, the statute that governs memorials on federal land in the capital. She wrote that the government “complied with none of these procedures,” that Congress has not enacted a statute authorizing the arch, that the National Capital Memorial Advisory Commission was never consulted, and that no congressionally appointed sponsor is stewarding the work. Second, she found that the District of Columbia and the Commonwealth of Virginia are likely to suffer irreparable harm from traffic disruption once work begins, writing that the threatened harms “will materialize as soon as construction begins.”

Chutkan also examined the administration’s national security justification. The government has argued that the structure could house drones and serve security functions protecting the capital. The judge scrutinized that rationale and its late arrival in the case. At an earlier hearing, she asked whether the arch was “somehow intended to prevent assassination attempts against the president” when it would not be finished for three years.

The Justice Department has argued the opposite record. In filings before the order, government lawyers said Congress authorized a monumental feature at the site more than a century ago, when 166-foot columns topped by statues were approved and never built, and that the arch “fulfills that Congressional vision.” The department said the plaintiffs simply dislike the design and lack standing. It called the District’s concern about the project’s effect on endangered bats “nonsense,” noting that the arch would rise in “a traffic circle, not a forest or a bat cave.” It also objected to the judge’s earlier orders requiring the government to give notice within one hour of any approval and within thirty minutes of any construction activity, calling them “problematic notice injunctions,” and asked her to “just issue a decision” on motions that were already fully briefed.

The case began on February 19, when a group of Vietnam War veterans sued. The District and Virginia filed their own suit on October 31, and Chutkan consolidated the two. Commission chairman Mark Paoletta said the arch would complete “a project over a century in the making,” honor the nation’s veterans, and give Arlington National Cemetery the gateway it deserves. The administration has said work would run 20 hours a day for two to three years.

The order is temporary. It expires in 14 days unless extended, and it does not decide the merits. The government may seek relief from the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit. The Supreme Court earlier allowed construction of the White House ballroom to proceed over a similar challenge.

The commission approved the project at night, and the court stopped it before the next morning.

Sources
https://www.courthousenews.com/federal-judge-preemptively-blocks-arc-de-trump/
https://lawandcrime.com/high-profile/just-issue-a-decision-doj-ridicules-nonsense-concerns-about-trump-archs-impact-on-bats-snipes-at-judges-problematic-injunctions/
https://www.washingtontimes.com/news/2026/nov/5/judge-tanya-chutkan-delays-work-trump-triumphal-arch-planning/
https://www.npr.org/2026/11/06/nx-s1-6031990/trump-arch-planning-commission-injunction

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here