Obama-Appointed Rhode Island Judge Permanently Blocks DOJ Immigration Conditions on Public-Safety Grants

0
267

By Jennifer Sanchez CBNC News

Chief U.S. District Judge John J. McConnell Jr. of the District of Rhode Island permanently prohibited the Department of Justice on Wednesday, November 4, 2026, from enforcing certain immigration-enforcement cooperation conditions on federal public-safety grants for a coalition of plaintiff states. McConnell, nominated by President Barack Obama in 2011, confirmed on May 4, 2011, and chief judge since 2019, held that DOJ exceeded its authority by attaching immigration requirements to grant programs Congress created for state and local criminal justice.

The plaintiff coalition was led with participation from New Jersey Attorney General Jennifer Davenport and included New Jersey, twenty-one other states, and the District of Columbia. The challenged programs include the Edward Byrne Memorial Justice Assistance Grant program, commonly called Byrne JAG, and related crisis-intervention and juvenile-justice funding streams. The Trump administration conditions required grant recipients to cooperate with federal immigration authorities by providing access to people in custody suspected of immigration violations, notifying federal officials before release, and complying with requirements concerning immigration-related information.

New Jersey’s Byrne allocation for fiscal year 2025 was approximately $4.2 million, with roughly $2.7 million allocated through a related crisis-intervention program. Across fiscal years 2019 through 2024, New Jersey received more than $21 million in Byrne funding. Crisis-intervention grants to the state exceeded $8.3 million for fiscal years 2022 through 2024. Those dollars have supported county anti-gang and narcotics task forces, protective equipment, undercover investigations, body cameras, Megan’s Law enforcement, ballistics laboratory work, and programs pairing officers with mental-health clinicians.

The dispute did not begin with Byrne JAG. In 2025 the Trump administration attached immigration conditions to more than $1.3 billion in Victims of Crime Act funding. States sued. The government later removed those conditions from VOCA. DOJ then placed similar cooperation requirements on other criminal-justice grants. The coalition filed an amended complaint on August 21 challenging the new conditions. States argued that Congress set formulas and eligibility rules without authorizing immigration-cooperation riders, and they raised constitutional anti-coercion and administrative-law claims.

Davenport called the ruling a victory against efforts to “unlawfully politicize law enforcement” by threatening funding. The permanent injunction protects the plaintiff jurisdictions. It is not described in the available reporting as a nationwide order covering non-party states. Scorecard analysis does not apply. This is a single-district-judge permanent prohibition, not a multi-justice appellate or Supreme Court vote.

The holding’s operational effect is clear for America First immigration enforcement. Federal grant leverage that conditioned public-safety dollars on custody access, release notice, and information cooperation is blocked for the coalition that sued. Local and state agencies in those jurisdictions may continue to draw Byrne and related funds without accepting the immigration-cooperation terms DOJ sought to attach. The court framed the issue as statutory and administrative overreach rather than as a policy preference about border enforcement.

McConnell’s order leaves the Trump administration without that particular funding tool against the plaintiff states unless a higher court reverses or Congress rewrites the grant statutes. The America First side lost the leverage question in Rhode Island federal court on November 4. The opinion does not erase immigration law. It does permanently restrain DOJ from enforcing the challenged conditions on the named grant streams for the jurisdictions that prevailed.

Readers should note the appointing president, the date of confirmation, and the chief-judge status because those facts identify who issued the permanent block. The plaintiff roster, the Byrne and crisis-intervention dollar figures, the VOCA precursor fight, the August 21 amended complaint, and Davenport’s statement are the verified record supporting the holding as reported.

Sources
https://jerseyvindicator.org/2026/11/04/federal-judge-blocks-trump-administration-from-tying-police-grants-to-immigration-enforcement/
https://www.fjc.gov/history/judges/mcconnell-john-james-jr
https://wrnjradio.com/new-jersey-attorney-general-multistate-coalition-win-court-ruling-protecting-federal-law-enforcement-funding/
https://migraprep.com/en/news/mcconnell-doj-byrne-jag-immigration-grant-conditions-blocked-2026-11-04/

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here