Andrew Durand and Kelsee Kimmel with the company of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, at the Public.
Photo: Joan Marcus
Is there an American writer whose tone has been more consistently turned on its head in adaptation than F. Scott Fitzgerald? Somehow, we persist in presenting The Great Gatsby’s allegory of national delusion and fraudulent ambition as a lush, louche true-love story, and now, joining the Fitzgerald theatrical pantheon, we have a chest-thumpingly earnest, hale, hearty, and wholesome interpretation of The Curious Case of Benjamin Button, the author’s 1922 short story about a man who’s born old and ages backwards.
Calling Jethro Compton’s musical — he directs on a set he designed, he wrote the book,…




