Commentary
It seemed simple enough as we closed out the 20th century. The role of courts was to apply longstanding rules of evidence to ferret out the truth, the whole truth, and nothing but the truth. In a criminal case, the evidence had to prove the facts necessary to establish guilt beyond reasonable doubt. On the other hand, in a civil case, the plaintiff’s burden was to prove the facts triggering civil liability on a balance of probabilities.
This remains the case today. It remains harder to secure a criminal conviction than a civil judgment because it is easier to prove that something happened on a balance of probabilities than beyond a reasonable doubt.
But the rules of evidence—such as the hearsay rule and the assessment of individual actions—have undergone something of a transformation over the last 30 years, largely as a result of what is commonly called woke ideology…




