Commentary
On Oct. 7, Justice Minister Sean Fraser announced that the federal government will not proceed with plans to expand MAID (medical assistance in dying) to people whose sole underlying medical condition is mental illness. Legislation will be introduced this fall to maintain their exclusion indefinitely. Until that legislation is passed, the current exclusion is still scheduled to expire on March 17, 2027.
But questions remain, and the “right to die” debate will continue before, during, and long after legislation is in place.
After all, we live in a society where it is easy to help people die, and so much harder to help them live. Most significantly, the debate over allowing MAID for mental illness raises two key questions: Is the request for MAID always a desire to die? Or could it be a veiled ask for help to live?
An Ontario court recently upheld the rules barring those…




