On September 14, the two most-watched public companies in pet retail shared the same Goldman Sachs stage and offered very similar messages from very different starting places. Chewy, Inc. (NYSE:CHWY) is attempting to persuade investors that it has outgrown the term “online pet retailer” entirely, while Petco Health and Wellness Company, Inc. (NASDAQ:WOOF) is aiming to convince them that its lengthy turnaround has finally reached the growth phase.
Chewy’s Platform Pitch, Delivered Under Pressure
Chewy CEO Sumit Singh’s fireside chat was focused on a platform narrative, not a retail one. He pointed to a long-running structural margin story: gross margins have expanded from 18% at Chewy’s IPO to around 30% today, driven by the company’s Autoship subscription program, health services expansion, and supply chain improvements. Chewy Health, the company’s…




