Rock and a Hard Place: Is There a Viable Alternative to Trial by Jury in America Today?

0
119

If the lone male juror isn’t the hero we need, he may very well be the hero we deserve.

I’m talking, of course, about the African American man who refused, against the wishes of the other 11 jurors—nine female, two male—to find Lindsay Clancy not guilty of the murder of her three children by reason of mental disease or defect.

His lone stand may not, in fact, conjure Horatius Cocles defending the pons Sublicius against the rampaging Etruscans, as some of us initially thought; nor indeed Spengler’s legionary who refused to abandon his post during the eruption of Vesuvius, simply because no-one had told him to do so—forgive me that reverie, please. But the case does, at least, tell us something about the nature of justice in America in 2026: where America is, and where she’s heading.

The tl;dr? Nowhere good and somewhere even worse than that. Sorry.

On…

Read more…

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here