In the classic movie 12 Angry Men, the legendary actor Henry Fonda stands alone as a single juror in arguing the potential innocence of a young defendant charged with murder. He eventually convinces the 11 other jurors to concur. What we have now witnessed in the Lindsay Clancy trial is something of a mirror image of that narrative, a single juror taking it to the limit in refusing to join his fellows. Only this time, instead of one juror being able to turn the other 11 his way, by all accounts, 11 were unable to swing the one holdout their way, thus singlehandedly forcing a mistrial in one of the most high-profile cases of the 21st century.
Rarely have the American people witnessed a trial where, in the eyes of most observers, the prosecution and defense offered up equally compelling narratives. No one has argued that Clancy’s three children were killed by anyone but their…




