Though the modern state successfully frames itself as the ultimate guarantor of positive rights, it is the opposite: a systematic violator of negative property rights. This is possible because the modern state is associated with the advent of the rule of law. To understand why society remains so blind to the ever-expanding “legal spoliation” by the state (to use Bastiat’s expression), it is necessary to look at the inherent duality between the psychological universality of property and its messy historical reality.
As Rothbard and others have noted, there is an instinctive sense of self-ownership of one’s own body, which led even die-hard communists to implicitly recognize private property. Human beings naturally feel they “own” something they have built or created, and they feel wronged when something they “possess” is taken from them without their consent. Such…




