The year was 2016. I was deputy commander of a Military Police battalion in one of the most dangerous neighborhoods of the capital of Pará—one of the poorest and most violent states in Brazil. At 3:40 in the morning, the radio broke into an intense exchange of dispatches, unusual for a Wednesday. The operations center gives me the picture: a sequestro relâmpago in progress, the “lightning kidnapping”: criminals take over the victim’s car at a traffic light and force cash withdrawals from ATMs. I head to the scene. It looked like a movie—negotiators, press, ambulances. The negotiation ran past sunrise, and at six o’clock the two kidnappers surrendered without hurting anyone. Both were 19 years old.
That same afternoon—to absolutely nobody’s surprise—they were already out. At the custody hearing, a procedure whose underlying goal, in practice, is to decarcerate (an…




