Recently, Ryan McMaken posed a provocative question: if the French are willing to number their republics, why not Americans?
The French, after all, openly acknowledge that their political order has undergone multiple transformations. The current French regime is known as the Fifth Republic, reflecting a succession of constitutional and political systems stretching back to the Revolution of 1789. No French historian would claim that the republic governed by Charles de Gaulle was identical to that governed by Adolphe Thiers simply because both called themselves republics.
Americans, however, tend to insist that they still live under the same republic established by the Founding Fathers. The Constitution ratified in 1788 remains in force. Politicians still swear oaths to it. Schoolchildren still learn to revere it. Therefore, many conclude that the American republic remains essentially…




