Photo-Illustration: Vulture
Was the last book you read good, or was it “BookTok good”? Critics of TikTok’s most popular novels cast them as poorly written and appealing to readers with less discerning tastes. I’m familiar with the argument and wary of the impulse to generalize about genre-fiction readers — romance novels have long been dismissed in similar terms. Even so, I’ve yet to find my next favorite romance on BookTok or Bookstagram, where conversations so often return to tropes.
I get the appeal. Romance tropes offer a shorthand for the pleasures a novel promises: the relationship dynamic, sexual content, or emotional terrain readers can expect on the way to a guaranteed happy ending. But they reveal only so much….




