When the South African government first proposed to enact a law permitting them to expropriate any property without compensation, the then conservative UK Prime Minister Teresa May said this would be fine as long as the government does it legally. She missed the point. The whole purpose of the law was to ensure that it is legal for the government to do exactly that.
The case of legal expropriation without compensation shows the importance of Friedrich Hayek’s rejection of “mere legality”—in Hayek’s theory of the rule of law, it is not enough that a rule be duly enacted into law. It must also maximize individual liberty and minimize government coercion. By Hayek’s test, the South African expropriation law fails to meet the requirements of the rule of law.
Murray Rothbard would go further, and he would reject any law allowing the government to steal property from citizens as…




