Murray Rothbard’s “The Mantle of Science,” is an immensely rich paper, and in what follows, I’m going to discuss a few of the many ideas in it. The key point in the paper is that human beings cannot properly be studied by the methods of the physical sciences, because humans are conscious and engage in choice. This point, which is of course the basis of praxeology, will be familiar to most readers, but many of the arguments Rothbard gives for this thesis are startling.
We can see, for example, why Rothbard liked Hans Hoppe’s “performative contradictions” so much. Drawing from the Scholastics, Rothbard used the same type of argument, called an argument from retortion, in this essay, which originally appeared in 1960. In this type of argument, someone’s thesis is shown to be false by the very fact that he advances it. As Rothbard puts it, using the example of the denial…




