In August 2024, the band Deer Tick were out for an old-fashioned Italian dinner when the band’s founder, John McCauley, began pitching his bandmates on his grand idea for their next album. He envisioned a record based on the group’s shared hometown of Providence, Rhode Island, with every song set around the city, including, perhaps, the very restaurant at which they were dining, the Old Canteen, a mid-century red sauce spot that hosted everyone from Frank Sinatra to Providence’s infamously mob-affiliated mayor Buddy Cianci.
“I remember John specifically saying, ‘This is the assignment,” recalls drummer Dennis Ryan, who was so inspired by the meeting that he went home and immediately finished a song called “507 Smith.” It was a fictionalized account of the time Ryan and McCauley lived together in a ramshackle house at that address. One lyric — “have a fresh…




